The quality of either should be fine. I have a Wenonah Cormorant, which is a pretty basic paddle (I normally use bent-shafts, but wanted a basic straight, and they had them on sale at the time). That appears to be the only wood straight shaft they have. Bending Branches has a much wider selection. Once you start trying different blades, you'll find some designs that you like better than others regarding aesthetics, function, length, as well as materials. I have lots of bent shafts collected over the years of different lengths, design, and construction.