• The 2026-29 Fund Drive needs 22 MORE DONATIONS to reach target. Read the Featured Thread for details. Please donate!!!

Need suggestions!

Joined
Apr 8, 2017
Messages
47
Reaction score
14
Location
Wyoming County, NY
I will be attending paddlefest in Old Forge in 2 weeks to test and probably purchase a new canoe. Most of my canoeing experience has been fishing on small ponds and lakes in my wenonah 14' fisherman. I want to expand that to do some solo day trips and a few overnighters on bigger water. I'm looking for something light, money not really an issue (as long as my wife doesn't see this!). I'm retired, 5' 11" 230. I don't think I'll be doing much river travel, mostly lakes. What would you more experienced paddlers suggest?
 
How much do you have to spend ?

Some of these new canoes can substantially lighten your billfold !

Jim
 
Just bought a new Swift Prospector 16 its dual use, it's a Tandem but being symmetrical you can spin it around and paddle in bow seat, it's a solo @32-36 pounds.
 
I will be attending paddlefest in Old Forge in 2 weeks to test and probably purchase a new canoe. Most of my canoeing experience has been fishing on small ponds and lakes in my wenonah 14' fisherman. I want to expand that to do some solo day trips and a few overnighters on bigger water. I'm looking for something light, money not really an issue (as long as my wife doesn't see this!). I'm retired, 5' 11" 230. I don't think I'll be doing much river travel, mostly lakes. What would you more experienced paddlers suggest?

Yeah, that's what I thought. ;)

First off - it goes against the popular thought here, I think, but that Fisherman is actually a pretty decent canoe for your use. And it does pretty well on up to class 2 rivers too. So - I'd hang on to that if you have the room.

Probably would advise against anything resembling a Prospector for your stated use. I love mine, but it's not what I reach for when heading to the lake. Too vulnerable to the wind having its way with it. Yeah, you can do things to mitigate that, but unless this is a "one and only for all uses", there are much better choices for primarily lake use.

At your size, I think I would be looking for something 15' or longer and about 28-32" wide for a solo.
 
Probably would advise against anything resembling a Prospector for your stated use. I love mine, but it's not what I reach for when heading to the lake. Too vulnerable to the wind having its way with it. Yeah, you can do things to mitigate that, but unless this is a "one and only for all uses", there are much better choices for primarily lake use.

For “mostly lakes, solo day trips and a few overnighters” I’d probably stay away from most modern Prospectors. Maybe Clipper’s 14 foot Prospector solo, but that is still a lot of freeboard lightly loaded in the wind, and you won’t find one on the east coast.

http://www.clippercanoes.com/14-foot-prospector/


At your size, I think I would be looking for something 15' or longer and about 28-32" wide for a solo.

Yeah, at 5’ 11” and 230 lbs a lake sheerline depth canoe at 15 feet would seem a good choice, maybe a little less max wide than 32 inches.

Length depends on how you pack for an overnighter. If you are a gear heavy glamper you may not want much less than 15 feet for ample below-gunwales gear storage. If you are a gram weenie one-pack tripper the extra length is unnecessary.

Beyond length and width I believe the bottom shape cross section has more to do with my wobbly, seated paddler comfort considerations than anything else. When seated in a round/elliptically bottomed canoe designed for kneeling I feel like an inebriated pig riding a unicycle, and I really don’t wanna be on my knees all the time.

My personal acid test for paddling seated: Can I turn my head and torso to look 180 degrees behind me, or grab a small dry bag or Pelican box from behind the seat and swing it forward between my knees?

If I can’t do that, at least in unchallenging conditions without an instant brace, I keep looking.

BTW, “I’m retired”. Me too, and the lighter the canoe the more it gets used these days. At a certain age weight becomes a now (and even more so in the future) consideration, especially if dropping big $’s on a canoe you may be paddling for decades to come.

I still lust after a Placid RapidFire as a lake daytrip canoe. Hell, it might be enough to turn me into a gram weenie for weekend trips.
 
Flat bottom with a keel? Usually pretty stable and symmetrical ones paddle fine both as a solo and a tandem.
 
A Swift Keewaydin 15 Pack boat in Carbon Fiber is a great solo boat for a larger person and some gear on lakes! You said money was not an issue right! Lol

Mine has been great for me and I am 6'4" 230lbs with 60lbs+ of gear

Edit - only if you are looking for a solo canoe
 
Back
Top Bottom