I've tried longer paddles. I've tried everything. That's why I have over a dozen double bladed paddles. Bending Branches made a double blade, they called a canoe paddle, that was something like 260 cm. I gave it away.
My thinking is, get the length you would get if your boat was a kayak and you weren't worried about water in the boat. There is a reason you don't see kayakers with really long paddles. They are really inefficient and cumbersome. If you use Werner's sizing chart I think it's plenty generous. I hope you like your paddle, but I think you'd have been happier if you'd just gotten used to using a shorter paddle.