We have multiple decent canoes for paddling, i don't plan to give up paddling anytime soon.
I've always wanted to try a sidemount outboard. My wife's uncle offered us his old Grumman 17' canoe that was a already registered as a motorboat so we accepted it. After searching for a suitable used outboard, I realized people must rarely sell their 2-4hp motors.
This winter I started looking at new outboards. Outboardmotorsonline had an overstock of 2.5 jp Suzukis for a little over $600.00 so we bought one. The primary reason for the 2.5 hp Suzuki was weight, it's only 29 pounds. Time will tell if I made the right choice.
Some of our small lakes are now becoming ice free so I'm looking forward to trying it out. I'm reluctant to try it for the first time until the water temperature is a little above freezing.
Good luck with your decision, keep us posted on how it all works out for you.