• Happy National Zipper Day (pat. 1913)! 🤐

Keeping fish simple

Joined
Jul 11, 2014
Messages
5,054
Reaction score
3,963
Location
Ontario Canada
from A Life In The Bush, Lessons From My Father by Roy MacGregor...
catching, cooking and eating fish in the bush with his father Duncan and Native friends.

"The women had large loaves of bread out and were slicing them on a board, thicker slices than I had ever seen. They looked big enough, and soft enough, to sleep on. There was pop out, and black tea boiling in an open pot."
"The fish were cleaned, but with the tails and heads left on and no effort made to remove the bones."
"The older man...had the huge skillet out and over the fire and was dumping in a large tin of butter. The butter sizzled and bubbled and blackened and hissed. It seemed to me as if he had accidentally put too much in the pan, for it seemed a cauldron of butter, but this, apparently, was exactly the way he wanted it. He dropped in several of the speckled-head, tails, bones and all."
"There were plates, real china, and everyone took one and lined up with their sliced bread and empty plates. The older woman came and pasted butter all over my bread. She said it would make the fish taste better. But all I could think about was the bones."
"When my turn came, the older man placed four or five nice-sized speckles on my bread, the grease and butter staining the bread black as he spooned them in.
I looked at Dunc."
""Go ahead" he said. "Indian style.""
"The other man howled with laughter. Over the fish and fire smells, I could smell more beer."
"I placed the other piece of bread over my death sandwich and turned to see what everyone else was doing. They all had the same sandwich I did, heads sticking out one end, tails the other. And they all were staring at me, waiting for the guest to begin."
"I picked up the huge sandwich and bit in from the side. I do not believe I had then, nor have I since, ever eaten anything that exploded with such desire in my mouth. Never had bread or butter or fish tasted so good."
"I could hardly wait for the next bite. I bit in, my eyes closed, and felt the grease and butter and fish run out my mouth and down my chin. I chewed, aware now that there were small bones, but they had all the substance of sardine bones and were instantly forgotten."
"There were pies out now, large sweet-smelling raspberry and blueberry pies, and they were being cut into huge slices and dumped right onto the same plates that were still black and slippery from the fish. I took raspberry, and it seemed the mixture made it even more delicious."
 
Last edited:
"... I chewed, aware now that there were small bones, but they had all the substance of sardine bones and were instantly forgotten."
When I was a kid, we used to fish for speckled (brook) trout in the small brook that ran behind our house. The "legal" minimum length was six inches but we'd keep whatever we caught because most of them were stunted due to the lack of (or competition for) food and didn't get much longer than six inches anyway. A seven inch trout would be one of the big ones. * Those little brookies were gutted as soon as they were caught and placed in grass and ferns in a wicker creel and occasionally dunked into the cold brook water to keep them cool. When we got back to the house, those little brookies were pan fried in butter for a late lunch or early supper. You could eat them tail, fins, bones and all. Served with some cold homemade baked beans and fresh bread they were a feast.

One time we had a picnic gathering at our house and a small gang of us kids went fishing for brookies. We went way up the brook and came back with a mess of fish, all excited about our catch. But a couple of the dads started laughing and joking about the "puny little fish" we'd caught, wondering why we even bothered with them. Our dad, though, knew better and cheerfully grilled them in butter for us over the barbecue fire. Well, you should have seen the look on the skeptic's faces as they bit into a crisp, buttery, freshly caught little brookie.

* To those questioning the rationale of letting kids keep "illegal" trout: The fishing pressure on that little brook back then was basically us and our friends, we weren't making much of a dent in that trout population. Plus, my dad hated to put a hook-injured five inch brookie back into the water knowing it probably wasn't going to live much longer anyway, either from the injury or it's life cycle. I think he knew something about brook trout because in the Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department's Annual Report, "Evaluation of Wild Brook Trout Populations in Vermont Streams" - Project No. F-36-R-19 (2017), they found that the types of streams we were fishing had dense populations of those slow-growing, short-lived brook trout, and that they rarely exceeded six inches in length. And further, that due to those conditions, a six-inch minimum length limit wasn't contributing much to the protection of wild brook trout populations. Apparently my dad already knew that more than 50 years before that report came out.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the memory.

My dad and I would go to a creek where he grew up and fish the babbling rocky stream there. Most trout caught were 'stockies" from a state fish hatchery. The minimum size to keep was also 6 inches with a maximum number of 10/day. We tried to throw the little ones back if they were not badly hooked. We did the same as you with damp grass and my dad's wicker creel.

When I started very young and small wearing short rubber boots, Dad would carry me over the deepest parts of the creek in his hip waders to the best producing deeper holes. I’ll never forget the time I caught a trout in mid-carry when I lifted my pole the darn thing was flopping all over in our faces. Eventually feet were soaked anyway and I just walked the stream. Occasionally we would get an orange bellied "native" trout up to about 10-12 inches long with orange flesh. What a treat. A couple of times my mother came along with a cast iron fry pan and would harvest wild leeks to cook with fresh trout streamside. Yum.

I hated the quick swimming dace that stole my worm and especially the terribly big ugly red face horned dace. My grandfather still lived not far away and we would sometimes visit after fishing. I couldn't understand him very well, as he spoke mostly in Polish with Dad. My dad could understand him, but replied mostly in half Polish half English. Then Grandpa would go to the cabinet and pour a glass for the two of them and a tiny amount for me with a few of those little after-dinner mint candies. I am pretty sure it was only sherry, so it was not very strong, but it seemed strong to me at my age.
 
Last edited:
When I was in college at Paul Smith's in 1971-1973, I rented a house in Gabriels, NY with 3 other guys for something like $70 per month. Oftentimes there were monumental weekend parties and usually a dozen folks would crash at the old place after an evening of drink and making merry. I was the only trout fisherman in the bunch and had a sweet spot I used to fish back in the brush on an old beaver pond. There were many times I rose early, hiked 2+ miles to the pond, caught a bunch of barely legal brook trout on flies, and fried them up to serve our "guests" breakfast when they awoke mid to late morning. I always dipped them in a little flour and fried them up crispy with the head and tails on. Will never forget those carefree days!
Dan
 
DJ, I just missed you I was at Paul Smiths from 1974-1976, I too lived in Gabriels share house for a bit till moved into an apartment in Saranac Lake.
All this is making me want to take up fishing.
Jim
 
Back
Top Bottom