• Happy World Photography Day!

Canoe paddle collectors

Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
77
Reaction score
53
Location
Minnesota
Calling all canoe paddle collectors: consider posting any pictures or comments relating to some of the paddles you have enjoyed, kept, broken, or moved on down the line.

I am hoping you all will help to curate an authoritative and centralized thread on nice paddles, paddle characteristics, and paddle preferences. There are so many nice paddles out there, many of which are no longer available as new, and for which there is very little information online. I’ll add measurements and takes to my posts as I go.

A post on the board this week indicated a milestone of membership and administrative desire to grow the canoe-focused brand. In that spirit I’m trying to start something I see as an empty info niche at present. While there are some threads here and on other forums, they seem to be more narrow than might benefit a broad consideration. I’ve learned a lot from many folks on this board I hope will drop by with some perspective, images, and opinions.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
77
Reaction score
53
Location
Minnesota
Here are two Puddicombe paddles I sold recently. I bought four of them a couple of years ago. I still have one that fits me well, though it rarely gets used. Interestingly all of these had length labels that were 1” too long, in comparison to other paddles I have. For example, these were labeled 52” and 53” but those measurements must have been taken around the bend, the long way. The one labeled 53” was the exact same length as a Mitchell I own labeled 52”. Both measured 52” tip to tip on the non power face side, the short way. Either way they are beautiful sticks with durable epoxy finish and rock guard. I believe these are either 14° or 15° bends. These were in the 17-20oz range, heavier than some Puddicombes are reported to be, and noticeably blade heavy. These were also sold under the name wildwood, as indicated by the paddle sock branding.320B86C9-E0FB-4513-8CBE-3A30C86C9E0A.jpeg00BE6467-D271-488D-B863-14271406C3E4.jpegFC72ECFA-9BF8-491F-8D88-5E682E41FF20.jpegEC82E487-B285-4C46-AD14-D91B1FC8602B.jpegB70FB5D1-9AAA-4461-947B-65DA5BD85A72.jpeg
A0184BBA-B987-4DE6-8679-9E364AA04316.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
77
Reaction score
53
Location
Minnesota
Some whitewater paddles I use without regard for their future. The Werner bandit in their orange fiberglass layup is incredibly well suited to the level of beatering I so regularly achieve in whitewater. Here you can see a new one and one after a few seasons. I paddle on the left mainly in whitewater and the glass bandit wears down like a graphite pencil. At 24-27oz, not a light paddle but it is well balanced and stiff. I prefer it much more than the very flexible, all black aqua bound paddle, which I keep as a spare and loaner. The blue one is the Werner bandito, which is a smaller blade version of the bandit. I like it for shallow river touring. It doesn’t have quite as much bite when you really want it in whitewater. Anyway the bandito seems to have the same length spine as the bandit, so less to wear down. Incidentally I’ve also owned an all carbon bandit but found it much too stiff and painful for my shoulder.958A6AB5-4264-48B9-B9A0-02293CE016E1.jpegC1F93C99-E8DA-4101-8235-81DD3C47206D.jpeg02795B10-07F2-4EA0-B6A5-652EFEFB35FD.jpeg13F00144-64A1-4B07-B250-219798753493.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
77
Reaction score
53
Location
Minnesota
One more for now. This is a Quimby with a 32” shaft and small cruising blade, made on spec in 2019 and purchased new. Not light and not as well balanced as I prefer, but esquisite nonetheless. It seems beefy and durable and has proven to be an excellent tripping paddle. It’s all about the details with this paddle and I’ll post more pics later to showcase.9EFA40E2-4BFF-4B93-8507-A5438E12A61A.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
77
Reaction score
53
Location
Minnesota
Here is a bent shaft carbon paddle produced under the brand name Barton. The Bartons are not to be confused with the paddles made by Black Bart (Bud Moll). The power face is totally flat with no dihedral. The non power face has a dihedral that is notably hollowed.

My understanding is that the company started in Michigan and then was sold to a new proprietor in Minnesota. I’ve had paddles with labels from both places and they seem to be quite similar. I’d call them a medium weight build, in the 13-14oz range for a 50” paddle. They all have blades that are 8.75” wide and 18-19” to the throat with what I’d guess is a 14-15° bend. This one has a shaft with wrapped texture akin to a taped hockey stick. One I sold to a close friend has a smooth finish without the wrap and was more like 10oz with a notably lighter build, with a Minnesota label. I don’t have any pics but I have seen a straight shaft barton paddle that is slightly asymmetric (one and not two power faces). 38EC256F-1DBB-4F65-BF8A-01D5152334F9.jpeg55597E3A-5DD9-4A6E-9FD5-29C5B3564064.jpeg35F2655A-C7C4-442A-A60B-C83269BD7899.jpegFD6B8EFC-F1FB-4DC4-81BC-352F604C7269.jpeg19E34688-C84B-4A2E-A442-58A98CF9B564.jpeg7AC772FF-94EC-4FC2-8617-2282D4587EFF.jpeg697E5FCC-933F-48A1-9FC1-5F2C2640E72F.jpeg
 
Joined
Jun 22, 2017
Messages
842
Reaction score
315
Well kona, I'm not a collector but I think I'm older than you so happy to show a little respect for a few paddles from the 1990's and the folks behind them. I don't have exact weights.

A couple of matched cedar straight shaft Puddicombe paddles. They are quite light. Nice flex. Very comfy grips. Lots of taper in the shafts and quite full and oval in the middle by your lower hand. Totally clean in the water if not as knife-like as a Quimby or Moore. With the epoxy edge and fiberglass blade overlay they should be able to take hard use. Nice paddles and pretty darn sexy.

I really enjoyed and appreciate my interactions with Peter Puddicombe.20220707_152416.jpg
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jun 22, 2017
Messages
842
Reaction score
315
A couple of Grey Owl Freestyles. The one on left has a blade that was ground extra thin by Grey Owl at my request. They warned me it would be more fragile but I use my paddles and have damaged many Freestyles in low water. The blade eventually got the tip reshaped and reinforced with epoxy/carbon by Ron Sell of Unadilla Boatworks so it is better than new. I also reshaped the grip a little and it has some painted details from an Ann Arbor artist. It's slicker than snot in the water. Regular stock Freestyle on right. I like Grey Owl paddles.
20220707_152649.jpg
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jun 22, 2017
Messages
842
Reaction score
315
A 56 inch straight shaft made by Ron Sell of Unadilla Boatworks. Ron's big grips are super comfy. It's made of Spanish Cedar and pretty light. Comfy tapered shaft. It has a carbon fiber insert in the blade and can be used hard. I like the painted details. Ron makes nice paddles and this one is a pleasure to use.
20220707_152823.jpg
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jun 22, 2017
Messages
842
Reaction score
315
A one of a kind Moore Cue clone on the left made by Mike Thomsen of Thomsen Boats. It was a gift from my close paddling friend Brian Moll and the model is Forward Pry since that was my nickname for him ever since he jammed his paddle on some rocks going over a drop in the Huron River and launched himself right out of his Wildfire. Shown next to a real Moore Cue on the right in Sport construction. They had specs for weight, balance, & flex. Not a durable paddle with edges around 1mm but really quite special in deep water.

I really enjoyed and appreciate all of the interactions I had with Patrick Moore. I wish I had taken his canoe lessons when I had the chance.
20220707_152137.jpg
 
Last edited:
Joined
Feb 14, 2015
Messages
3,901
Reaction score
659
Location
Iowa
I too have a Puddicombe Wild wood paddle.

I remember buying it from him at one of the MidwestMountain's Spring events, years ago!

At the time, I purchased it for $200. He and his girl friend were there, selling his paddles. Yes an interesting, and entertaining couple !

I was worried going home and telling my Wife what I did ! Knowing the amount of money I spent !

Then I remembered her saying, she wanted to buy me a Terry Redlin print.

When I got home I told her that paddle was better than any Redlin print ! That was all that was said !!

Sorry if this offends the ladies ! But wrapping your hands around one of Peter's Wild wood paddles, is like holding Marylin Monroe !

I cherish mine ! only actually used it a few times. I prefer to beat up my old "BB Special". Over thirty years old, Bending Branches, has been reglassed twice. It has served me well !

Glad to see others with Peter's paddles !

Oh, mine is a bent shaft .

Jim
 

Glenn MacGrady

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
2,883
Reaction score
1,079
Location
Connecticut
This is a good idea to show off paddles, except most of us probably don't have good gallery pictures available. I do have a few.

Here is my most recent purchase, a Bruce Smith ottertail made of butternut with dark walnut inlays on the shaft and grip. My thread on this paddle seemed to have spurred about four other members to buy paddles from Bruce.

Bruce Smith Ottertail Full2.JPG

DSCN2911.JPG

Bruce Smith Ottertail Shaft2.JPG

These are two Wenonah Black Lite 10° bent shaft paddles I also bought in 2021.

2021-03-22-paddle-Heap-0004.jpg

This trio, from left to right, is a 30-year old Mitchell straight shaft, curved blade whitewater paddle; a 38-year old Blackburn Brothers 2.5° Lutra Pro S blade paddle (designed by Mike Galt); and a 32-year old Mitchell 15° Lutra S blade paddle.

Paddles back face.jpg

The following is not my paddle, but it is an actual picture of the first Blackburn Brothers Honey Island Cruiser paddle, a model that predated the Lutras. The Cruisers and Lutras were the ne plus ultra paddles of the early age of (freestyle) sport paddling in the '70's and '80's, when big blades and slow paddling cadences were the rage.

First Honey Island Cruiser.jpg

The two pictures below of my Huki V1-B outrigger canoe in the magical Sparkleberry Swamp of South Carolina show a carbon blade Mitchell Leader double bend paddle and a double scoop blade Sawyer Manta 11° single bend paddle.

Huki and paddles Sparkleberry.JPG

Huki and paddles 2 in Sparkleberry Swamp.JPG
 
Joined
Nov 25, 2021
Messages
473
Reaction score
237
Location
Florida
I am one of Glenn’s happy victims. Here is my 62”cherry Bruce Smith ottertail next to my 66” Fishell Ray Special.

FA3BC1BF-5271-45B3-BFD0-6B12CDB97E03.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Top