Everyone has something different that works for them.
I think so too. Just like walking, we each have our own particular gait, so why shouldn't we prefer our own particular footwear?
I used to resist the urge to stop and change footwear, seeing it as time wasting. On my quest to slow down in life (and it's been taking a lifetime to do this) I reasoned on our recent trips to apply the same laid back attitude to the moments
between paddle and path. I have no problem puttering across the portage and even less issue with lackadaisical lake crossings, it's the inbetween hassle hustle I'm needing to revisit. Anyway, it made all the difference to me to pause to sit, drink in the view, sip some water, and swap water shoes for trail boots. And repeat the forced non-march at the other end of the portage. I was happy. My feet were happy.
For some reason I'm happiest in my bias towards boots on my feet, even when they're impractical. It's when I'm shod in sneakers and sandals that my feet become clumsy. What the ffffeet?! And the slippy soles of water sandals mean they never make the trips anymore. However the full foot coverage of water shoes feels better in and out of the water, and the soles are surprisingly sticky on rock surfaces. I just don't like the lightweight feel of them on rocky rooty trails. I should try to get used to them I suppose. But I love the more solid feel of boots when carrying across portages. But they can't be trusted on wet roots and rocks. Oh the conundrum.
And speaking of footwear bias my older brother practically perpetually dresses like a beachbum. Even on canoe trips, or
especially on canoe trips, replete with old cotton t-shirt, silly beachy shorts and
flip flops. I have spied canvas Converse amongst his gear too. Groovy man. But I shouldn't judge, because he's happy, and apparently so are his feet. Come to think of it, I bet
he could give me lessons on doing the whole slowing down thang. Cool. But keep yer hands off my boots, dude.