Personnally i did not buy a lot of canoes where I could choose the color. and all the ones i have now are second hand and chosen my the model/shape and had nothing to do with the color. WHen i was racing kayaks i have had the chance to chose colors 2 that i still remember as very nice where a mango one and a black and green kawasaki style.
the only canoe i can remember having a choice of color was this one:
Old town made the next most years in 3 color if i remember well 2 dark ones and on that popped
I like dark green for my canoe and my Jeep, for the reason that it's unobtrusive and less noticeable in the woods. Plus, I really like the way the light colored wood looks against the dark green hull.
For those that like the vintage colors here are some old companies and their color charts.
First is Smiths, as near as I can guess from the 30’s or 40’s.
In the same vintage is Merkin.
An old Interlux color card, a company that is still in business but these colors are not available last time I looked.
And last is Kirby paint that still produces the vintage colors and they are a great company to do business with.
What about you? Do you have a color preference for canoes and does it change based on the construction of the hull or its intended use? What (in your opinion) is "too far" and have you ever gone there (either deliberately or inadvertently)?
When I first noticed your tie-dyed Merlin at WPASCR I thought: Hmm, interesting; but, yuck. Then I went over and saw that it was a stripper and appreciated the contrast between the beautiful wood interior and the "colorful" exterior. (Still yuck.)
I have preferences for canoe colors but I didn't choose the color of any of the canoes I own (or owned), other than between Swift's carbon fusion in either Black Carbon or Granite. Of the colors that came with the canoes, faded red Royalex was the least liked and I've never really liked boring white. I find clear-coat Kevlar and black carbon attractive, especially carbon with ash woodwork. Maybe that's because I associate Kevlar and carbon with light weight. I had a nice looking Dagger Genesis in teal Royalex with wood gunnels.
I had two Dave Curtis canoes with colors that I loved...