• Happy National Hunting & Fishing Day!🦌🦈

A little paddle maintenance - Bruce Smith & Fishell

Nov 25, 2021
Reaction score
I have gotten 2 new paddles since the holidays, and only used one: the 62” Bruce Smith cherry ottertail. I must say, I really love it. I was surprised how thin the shaft was upon receipt. I didn’t have an expectation I suppose, and didn’t think to discuss it with Bruce leading up to placing my order. I had measured my finger length and palm width for him to be sure the grip end would fit me well. And of course I followed his recommendation on shaft length. After my surprise about the shaft diameter (and FYI it is an oval in cross section, thicker front-to-back), I began using it every chance I got. It’s too long for some (most?) of the rivers near me but it goes along anyway for the portions where I can use it, or for downstream portions. It’s fantastic in lakes of course. The blade and the shaft are both flexible. It is easier to use for an extended period than a standard recreational or Sugar Island pattern or even a Grey Owl bent shaft. Maybe in some part because I’m still so excited about it? It is wonderful on underwater returns, I can palm roll it easily, and it’s delightful to use as I try to improve my technique.

After 4 or 5 local daytrips, I noticed some wear on the tip. Apparently the biggest threat to this paddle’s existence is being rubbed on the bottom of my canoe. So I dug up the maintenance instructions that came with it. Bruce says to mix up a batch of 85% BLO with 15% paint thinner or varsol. Ace had BLO and paint thinner, so that’s what I got. He suggests mixing it in a Ball jar and labeling it “Paddle Oil”. So I did. FYI, I didn’t fill the entire quart jar, I aimed for 24oz and further, the proportions come out awfully close to 20/4oz and wouldn’t you know, the jar is graduated thusly.


He suggested soaking the tip of the paddle in a container of the paddle oil at the end of each season to help protect the paddle. I didn’t do this today, I just wiped down the whole paddle especially the rub marks I’d found. Probably unnecessarily premature maintenance, but it wasn’t exactly a tomato stake either.

Now since I had this mixture ready to go, I also treated the shaft and grip of my as yet unused 66” Fishell “Ray Special”. I ordered it with a varnished blade and oiled shaft and grip, and new owners are advised to rub another coat of BLO on the shaft and grip before first use. I had just never got a Round Tuit, so there it lay on my bow rack collecting dust. Well today was the day! I followed the rest of Bruce’s instructions on the Fishell too and I’m pleased with the results. The finish is still thin. I did need to steel wool a spot on the grip where the grain lifted as it soaked up oil. So I will add a few more coats before using it.

The Bruce Smith paddle just has a fantastic glow about it, you want to touch it, caress it even. The Fishell is a lovely piece of cherry, but the shiny varnish lacks the glow and warmth of an oil finish. As it ages I may sand off the varnish and go oil on it as well. I may gently steel wool it anyway just to knock down the shine.

Here they be in all their black cherry glory!

Last edited:
I compared today’s pics to the website pics from when I ordered it. The cherry has already begun to darken some. You can tell because there is a thin strip of sapwood on the edge which either has not changed or is doing so much more slowly.

This is Bruce’s pic, not mine:

And in case anyone is curious, I weighed the paddles on my kitchen scale.

66” Fishell: 33-1/8 oz.
62” B Smith: 23-3/4 oz.
Gorgeous paddles and good documentation @Woodpuppy !

Re darkening of cherry, I have a cherry Fishell bought circa 2016/17, and two cherry Badgers bought early and late 2021 respectively. The Fishell is varnished, the Badgers oiled. I've been maintaining the Badgers with Tung oil semi-regularly (done full oiling, two thin coats each time, twice in the last year). I've noticed that already the Badgers have darkened noticeably in comparison to the Fishell, despite the Fishell being much older. I assume this is due to the UV protection of the varnish, even though Tung oil is also supposed to protect against UV to my knowledge.
@Woodpuppy, how long did you leave the oil on before wiping down? What did you wipe down with (cloth, steel wool, green scotchbrite pad, wet-dry sand paper)?

I've watched the video below and tried to follow the advice, despite the fact that I haven't been able to get Badger oil and am using a Tung oil that Bruce Smith said would do fine. Previously I'd done pure Tung oil. This time I did 50/50 BLO/tung, but with the same sneaking suspicion:
I've been told not to let the oil sit too long lest it get tacky, but rubbing the paddle down soon after, I feel like I'm just rubbing off what I applied.

Gotta leave it til it gets a little tacky then burnish it in. I just used a clean blue shop towel. You need a thickened consistency to rub it into and fill the grain. Otherwise, yeah it feels like you’re just wiping it off. Timing is something you just have to work out for yourself because temp and humidity play a big role.